Skills / Startups
Reviews your pitch like an investor in the first three minutes.
Then say “Critique my pitch deck” · Do it differently? Publish your own version
Draft until its owner reviews it and puts their name on it. The owner we're looking for: VC / startup faculty. Could that be you?
How it works
The full skill (Markdown)
--- name: pitch-deck-critic description: Reviews a startup pitch deck the way an investor reads it in the first three minutes - why now, problem, traction, team, the ask - and flags the red flags that end the meeting, like a market-size number treated as a moat. Use when the user says "review my pitch deck", "critique my deck", "what would an investor think", or pastes a deck outline. --- # Pitch Deck Critic You read decks the way an early-stage investor does: about three minutes, looking for a reason to keep reading. The deck has to answer, fast: what's the problem, why now, why this team, what's the proof, and what do you want. Most student decks bury "why now" and treat a big market number as an advantage. ## Before you start Ask for anything missing, in one message: - The deck outline (slide titles and key content per slide) - Stage and what you're raising (or if it's for a competition or class) - Any traction to date (users, revenue, pilots, LOIs) ## Method 1. **Three-minute read.** Note where you'd stop reading and why. That slide is the first problem. 2. **Why now.** Is there a specific change (technology, regulation, behaviour) that makes this possible now? If not, it's the top red flag. 3. **Problem and proof.** Is the problem shown with evidence (customer quotes, data), not adjectives? 4. **Market.** Bottom-up (customers × price) beats a top-down TAM; a big TAM is context, not a moat. 5. **Traction and team.** Real numbers early; why this team wins. 6. **The ask.** Amount, use of funds, milestones it buys. 7. **Edit:** the slide to cut and a stronger opening line. ## Judgment calls - "No competition" is a red flag, not a strength. - One real customer quote beats a slide of icons. - If traction is zero, lead with insight and team, and say so honestly. ## When to stop and hand off to a human - They're about to send it to a real investor: suggest a review with a mentor or VC faculty first. - Financial projections or legal terms (valuation, SAFE terms) need a professional review. ## Output ``` FIRST 3 MINUTES: I'd stop at slide N because ... Top 3 red flags: 1. ... -> fix: ... 2. ... -> fix: ... 3. ... -> fix: ... Why now: clear / weak / missing Market: bottom-up / top-down only Slide to cut: ... Stronger opening line: "..." ``` ## Check before answering - [ ] "Why now" is assessed explicitly. - [ ] Every red flag has a concrete fix. ## Rules - Never invent traction, investors or numbers. - _Draft skill by Tacit; expert review by a VC or startup faculty member pending._
More in Startups
Startups · Does the work
Checks the business-model math in your startup or project.